One of our family’s favorite menu items is make-your-own-sushi. In fact, judging by the reactions from our friends, sushi night seems to be a favorite for everyone. Over the years it’s gotten a little fancier, but it doesn’t have to be. When we first began doing vegan sushi nights, I would make the cut rolls… And the ingredients varied but usually included some baked tofu, cucumber, and avocado. Sometimes we’d have romaine lettuce, shredded carrots, or veggie “ham.” In other words, it really varied.
As our girls got older, and developed their incisors, sushi night got easier because I stopped making cut rolls. After all, making a lot of hand rolls is a lot faster. Then came the switch to “make your own.” I would prep the ingredients, and everyone would make their own roll. This was wonderful because it resulted in two things… 1) our girls’ food prep skills increased and 2) it gave me more time to focus on the ingredients and prepare a variety of fillings.
Recently, that extra time has also been used to explore the world of nigiri sushi. I know, this pushes me back into the crazy world of frenetically creating labor intensive meals, but the results are worth it, and it keeps me fresh with new ideas. In truth, the actual prep work increases a little, but not as much as. You’d think. Making nigiri isn’t as time consuming as making hand rolls or cut rolls, and the topping for the nigiri can often be the same ingredients you use for the hand rolls… Maybe cut in a slightly different way, but it can still be the same stuff.
Before I go into the different things I did for our last sushi night, I want to talk about su for a little bit. Sushi su is the vinegar mixture that you use to season the rice and give it that distinctive flavor that adds a bit of subtle depth of flavor and aroma. There are a lot of sushi su recipes out there. I’m sure that most, if not all, sushi chefs have their own twist to the recipe. Sushi su is essential. The fillings in rolls are important too, but the flavor and texture of the rice can make or break sushi. For me, the big thing is balance of flavor. Here’s my recipe.
Note: I use all organic ingredients. Non-organic work fine as well. It’s all about what you prefer.
4 cups of sushi rice. I use some medium grain brown rice, but short grain works too. White is fine, but I like the protein of brown.
1/2 cup rice vinegar (do NOT use seasoned rice vinegar… That’s a totally different ingredient with salt and sugar already added)
3-4 tablespoons agave nectar
1 and 1/2 tablespoons kosher sea salt
1/4 cup or more of toasted sesame seeds
Cooking Instructions:
This recipe uses four cups of rice. Adjust accordingly if you need less or more.
Rinse rice well until the water is more clear. Add water as per markings on the rice cooker. Let the rice sit in the water for about 30 minutes. If you don’t have a rice cooker, then get one. Yes, you can cook rice in a pot. It’s not that hard, but the days of measuring with a finger, watching for the water to boil, covering the pot, lowering the heat, and simmering till done are over. It’s so 20th century! Rice is much more consistent when it’s cooked in the rice cooker. Very little chance of burned bottoms with mushy middles and crunchy tops.
Start the rice cooker and wait. When it’s done, don’t open the rice cooker. Let it sit steaming and off for then minutes. Note: while the rice is cooking, you have time to prep all other ingredients you’re filling the rolls with or toast sesame seeds or read a few chapters in a book.
For the sushi su, you will mix all the ingredients together until there are no crystals of salt. Note: if you have no agave, sugar will do, but you might actually have to increase the sugar… Agave can be sweeter.
It’s time to season your rice. Put the rice in a large, shallow bowl. The traditional wood sushi containers are great, but ceramic works fine too. The key is shallow and wide. If the sides are high, but the bowl has a smaller diameter, then the rice won’t breathe enough and it’s far more likely to get mushy.
Put the rice in the bowl and pour a little (like two tablespoons) of the su over the rice. You want to pour it on the rice paddle so that it splashes more evenly over the rice. When you get more experience, try bouncing or shaking the paddle vertically while pouring the su on it… The su will splash and spray a lot more, but that’s what you want.
Mixing technique varies, but you want to be a thorough and gentle at the same time. It’s like folding in an ingredient to a delicate batter… But be thorough!
When the su is fully absorbed, add more sushi su and repeat folding. When you’ve used a little over half of the amount of sushi su, begin tasting the rice to check for enough seasoning. This is a personal preference thing.
When you’ve added all the sushi su you want to, sprinkle the toasted sesame seeds onto the rice and fold in throughly.
The rice is ready for sushi now!
Note: a lot of people, me included, get someone to fan the rice as you are adding the sushi su. This does two things… It cools the rice a little bit and it makes it shiny.
Variations: if you like a fresh citrus flavor, substitute some (not all) of the rice vinegar with fresh lemon juice. If you like the sesame flavor to be more pronounced, add a 1/4 teaspoon of toasted sesame oil. Black sesame seeds are a fun, colorful treat as well.










